John Osmond says that in going for the man rather than the ball the Carmarthen West MP risks falling over
The oldest game in politics is to characterise the policy or views of your opponent beyond all recognition, create an easy target and then knock it down. In sporting terms it might be compared with going for the man rather than the ball.
There was a pretty breath-taking, actually hysterical example in the Carmarthen Journal last week. In his column in the paper, which can also be viewed on his website here, Simon Hart, the Conservative MP for Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire, cries at full throttle that the forthcoming referendum on further powers for the Assembly spells the end of the UK:
“I believe we are at the top of the slippery slope to full independence. It’s time to pull back before it’s too late.”
And in a warning reminiscent of former Prime Minister John Major’s devolution wake-up call to the United Kingdom during the 1997 general election campaign he declares:
“Once again we could be sleepwalking into a situation from which there is no return – make no mistake this is creeping separatism we are witnessing.”
Once again? Oh yes, it’s the referendum on what was then known as the Common Market he’s bringing up:
“The Yes campaigners would have you believe that this is merely a minor adjustment to the way things already exist. A little ‘tidying up exercise’, they say, ‘nothing to worry about’. But the last time we heard this sort of argument was in the 1970s when we voted to go into Europe”.
The 47-year-old Simon Hart would have been only 11 or 12 in 1975 when the referendum on Europe was held, so it’s understandable that his recollection is a bit hazy. As someone who reported on it at the time I can tell him that no-one thought of it as some kind of ‘tidying up’ exercise. Figures such as Tony Benn, Michael Foot and Enoch Powell tried to put the fear of God into their audiences, with dire warnings that the sovereignty of Parliament was at stake and the end of the United Kingdom was nigh.
When I last looked the Houses of Parliament was still upright in Westminster. Indeed, only last week the Speaker’s wife Sally Bercow, dressed in a sheet at a window overlooking Big Ben, told the Evening Standard that living under it was something of a turn-on.
Get real Simon Hart. Aren’t you talking some of your opponents in your constituency up a bit? Here you go again:
“I like the Assembly and think by and large it does good work but it seems many people are afraid that the referendum is being hijacked by Nationalists who won’t rest until Plaid’s ultimate aim of an independent Wales is achieved.”
Suddenly, I have an image of Plaid leader, Ieuan Wyn Jones, the epitome of a safe pair of hands, hardly the type of personality to hijack the UK. I rest my case.
I wonder if Mr Hart talks to his constituency AM, Angela Burns, also a Conservative?
On her Twitter a/c Angela Burns tweeted on Feb 4th:
“Good launch Pembrokeshire Yes campaign last night. hope everyone understands Yes 4 Wales is not a yes 4 WAG. Blurred lines in communication”
Angela gets it – why doesn’t Simon?
The Torys want to reduce the number of Welsh MPs to 30, as well as banning Scottish MPs from voting on English only laws. If we get a Yes vote then Welsh MPs to an extent would also be included in this ban. Turkeys don’t vote for Christmas.
because Simon still thinks/wishes he is in Ingurland
Well said Mr Osmond. I presume Mr Hart also thinks it was them Reds wot forced us into Europe…!!!
In this three way marginal Mr Harts comments will drive voters who are more afraid of the ConDem Government than scaremongering over nationalism into the arms of Plaid. Labour voters have a history of switching to Plaid when there is a right wing government in London
Perhaps he needs to base his judgements on his head, not his Hart.
Perhaps we should consider other ‘slippery slopes’. Would Simon Hart agree that voting Tory is the ‘slippery slope’ to fascism? Following David Cameron’s recent speech on Britishness, perhaps this is a more likely scenario than the March 3rd referendum leading to independence.