Jonathan Bray argues that treating electrification of the Valley lines as just another engineering project would be a missed opportunity
Scotland got a comprehensive deal on transport powers as part of devolution and has forged ahead with some confidence – particularly on rail. The state of play on devolution of transport powers in Wales is less clear cut and remains complex and unresolved.
Small countries can do great things with transport. The Netherlands and Switzerland are among the best in the world on all sorts of measures of public transport integration – and of course the Dutch are world-beaters at cycling. Wales is positioning itself as a small country that can do great green things that make people want to live, work and invest there. For instance, its flagship transport measure, the Active Travel Bill, places an imperative on local transport authorities in Wales to prioritise cycling and walking.
However, with bus and rail the direction of travel is less clear cut, with powers uneasily divided between Wales and the absentee landlord in Whitehall.
There’s also an impasse on local transport governance. Wales is served by four local transport partnerships which bring together existing local authorities in a voluntary way. However, many believe that this isn’t enough to bring efficient and integrated arrangements for public transport services and ticketing – especially in the area which covers Newport / Cardiff / Bridgend and the Valleys.
This was certainly the impression that I got at two events in Cardiff that I took part in earlier this year. In the first I gave evidence at the National Assembly’s Enterprise and Business Committee. The second was the IWA’s conference on Making a Welsh Metro Happen, held in March.
Part of the context for this fresh impetus for the debate is that the Valleys are changing. The physical scars on the landscape left by primary industries are healing. Reclamation of the tip spoils has turned the Valleys in to a destination for green tourism. And although the social and economic scars are not so easy to heal there is change there too – with population on the increase after years of decline, and steady diversification of the Valleys’ economies. Meanwhile Cardiff now has the look and feel of a capital of a small country. Its growing big city economy is also the bedrock of the wider Welsh economy and more people are commuting into the city as a result.
The Valleys are linked to Cardiff by a rail network that makes the best of its basic stations and bottom of the heap rolling stock. Now the forthcoming electrification of the South Wales main line, and the Valley lines, offers the opportunity to do something special with the network. This would be doubly the case if the electrification was linked to the creation of a transport authority for the area that could make sure that faster services are linked in to a fully integrated bus network.
By the nature of their geography the Valleys are ideal for a hub and spoke system with rail providing the rapid links to Cardiff, and bus services radiating from key stations – all bound together by smart and integrated ticketing. Just treating the electrification of the Valleys as a rail engineering project with knock on benefits for rail passengers would be a major missed opportunity.
As ever though governance change is hard. Politicians and officers fear that they will lose out from the creation of a new body – either in terms of influence or responsibilities. Plus there’s an added difficulty with the Bridgend, Cardiff, Newport and the Valleys area. Nobody knows what to call it!
It’s not exactly a city region. Extending the Cardiff brand to cover it would neither be diplomatic nor quite accurate. Everyone knows what the area is – but there isn’t a word for it. What it could be though is a great place to live and work as the century progresses. The Green Valleys, Cardiff’s buzz – a big sub-region in a small country doing great things. Sometimes transport’s role can be overstated in transforming regions – but not here.
Core urban bus services, fast electric services to the Valleys’ hub stations for bus feeder networks. There should be one brand, one smart ticket, and one network binding local economies more closely together into a region that could hold its own. It’s there for the taking if the politicians are ready to take a leap forward on getting the powers they need from Whitehall and in taking some big, resolute decisions on bus regulation and transport governance.
The ‘Central South Wales’ transport region, or ‘South Wales Central’ transport region , would surely be an accurate enough name? A central name would easily take in, geographically, everywhere between Newport and Swansea, and everywhere up to Merthyr and the Heads of the Valleys.
Are we ever going to get somebody arguing for better rail service elsewhere in Wales other than for ‘Greater Cardiff’?
The organisation that plans, co-ordinates, acquires and markets the public transport of the city of Oslo and its neighbouring authority, Akershus, is simply called ‘Ruter’ (derived, I think, from road/route) and elegantly sidesteps the geographical sensibilities of the residents of both the capital city and its surrounding hinterland.
“Are we ever going to get somebody arguing for better rail service elsewhere in Wales other than for ‘Greater Cardiff’?”
David, the floor is all yours.
My reason for not arguing for better rail service elsewhere in Wales is not because I’m not in favour of it, but rather that I don’t know what the demand for changes is in other regions of Wales. I have heard talk of reopening the branch from Bangor to Caernarfon. There is the perennial call for the reopening of the line between Aberystwyth and Carmarthen, and I personally would like to see a line crossing the Brecon Beacons to connect Cardiff with the Wales beyond Merthyr, first stop Brecon. However, what this discussion needs is to hear from other regions of Wales and what they would like to see from a national rail service.
I think if we want to demonstrate we are a politically mature region, with a coherent and shared vision around attracting economic development and significant investment, we place the interests of our aggregated population at the forefront of our collective minds and name our region after our principal city, conveniently also the capital of Wales. The “Cardiff City Region” seems the obvious choice to me and would be so whether I lived in Newport, Merthyr, Caerphilly, or Pontypridd .